Cake Mix Cookie Bars Recipe

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Questions & Reviews

1. Ashley says:

   I can't wait to make these! They look amazing! FYI, the Nutter Butter Cookie Bar link isn't working (it's linked to the Gingerbread one). Going to search for that one since it looks amazing, too! :)
2. kate says:

   Ah, sweet torture ! My mouth literally started watering at seeing that picture.
3. plasterer bristol says:

   This sounds amazing, thank you for posting up this recipe. Simon
4. Susan says:

   Great recipe! I have not yet made the original recipe, but have tried it with Spice cake mix and Hershey's Cinnamon Chips. Another variation that I've made is with Devil's Food cake mix and Reese's Peanut Butter Chips. Both were awesome!
5. Sandy says:

   The spice cake mix version sounds wonderful also! Did you use the 1/2 cup of milk chocolate chips or all cinnamon chips? Thanks!
6. Susan says:

   Ann cinnamon chips and saved some to sprinkle on top. Thanks for sharing the recipe!
7. Susan says:

   Sorry, that should have been ALL cinnamon chips... :)
8. kathy says:

   Happy Holidays made this today with strawberry cake mix an chocolate chips an was super yummy next will be another flavor for sure thanls
9. Sharon says:

   This is a mouthwatering cake! Love it :)
10. Laura says:

    I am making this to bring into work using white chocolate chips and red velvet cake. I just hope it turns out. The cake mix is just sitting in globs across the top and it's about halfway done baking. Wish me luck!
11. Heidi says:

    Ok, I had issues with this. I mixed up the box of cake mix with the eggs & oil & had trouble getting it to cover the bottom of the 9x13 pan. I ended up having to use a 2nd box of cake mix to put on the top. It looks like a hot mess! It tastes ok & is ooey, gooey but it just does not look right. Any suggestions?
12. Louise says:

    Heidi I am having the same problem--hopefully someone has an answer for us!
13. Meghan says:

    I used a spatula to flatten the mix out along the bottom of the pan.
14. Ivonne says:

    My family and I don't normally buy boxed cake mixes, but since my husband made a copy cat cake mix batter ice cream and only used 1/2 cup of the yellow cake mix that left us with 12.53 oz that I did not feel right throwing away. With this said I opted to go onto Pinterest and find something to make that my family could all enjoy. Thankfully I came across this recipe despite not having the exact ounce in cake mix nor a 9x13 pan. I was a little worried about the batter not working out, but I went ahead with the recipe so long as nothing else was tweaked i.e. oil and egg's. For those wondering I did used a 9x9 square baking pan that was perfect when it came to spreading my bottom layer of batter evenly. I used peanut butter and milk chocolate morsels that were already combined in one bag vs buying two separate bag's of each. After mixing, prepping, baking and cooling I decided I would then place my finished cookie bars in the fridge for later as a dessert and easier cutting. The cooked bars sat in the fridge for about 2 hours. And since the recipe said it serves 15, which I assume 1 cookie bar per person, I then cut each cookie square at exactly 2 & 1/8 inches - evenly. Having sat in the fridge and finally being able to dig into a bar my family and I can honestly say this recipe was AMAZING. We all loved the bars. So much gooeyness -even after being in the fridge. I opted to half the cooked bars and place some into the freezer for future as despite being a family of 5 we don't always eat sweets as dessert. This recipe is keeper!!! Notes: 9x9 square pan works best Cut each cookie bar 2 & 1/8 in for exact size You can get away with using, at minimum 12.53 ounces of boxed cake mix Still gooey if refrigerated & freezes well
15. Mary says:

    Thanks Ivonne! Your notes are a big help.
16. Jess says:

    Mine did the same thing ?
17. Krista says:

    I made these bars just as the recipe is on this website for a funeral this morning. They turned out perfectly!!!!! I made another batch tonight for us.
18. Dottie says:

    Could it be that the cake mix isn't the usual largest ounce? See that some boxes are about 11 ounces and formerly were 15+/-. Getting same money but smaller amount. Just like out Facial tissues today! Thanks for sharing this!!
19. Linda says:

    Made these twice now and they are super easy and fantastic tasting. Probably one of my favorite bars!
20. Celeste says:

    These cookie bars are DELICIOUS I put hafe on the bottom used my fingers to spread it and it worked great. Then for the top I took some dough and flattened it with my hands and layed it on top it works good that way. If you just put globs on top it won't spread out good. At least it didn't for me. This way worked for me!
21. Renate says:

    I thought that too at first. I sprayed some oil on my fingertips and it was easy to smooth out the smallish amount of batter to cover the bottom and it was plenty thick enough after cooking.
22. Destiny says:

    I made these and they were delicious but the bottom layer never crisp up to set up and was gooey. I did a very thin layer on the bottom. Any suggestions?
23. Taneshia says:

    Can I make this with cookie butter instead
24. Cyd says:

    We have not made this with cookie butter. Cookie butter has a much thicker consistency than butter. It's more similar to the texture of peanut butter. I'm not sure where you were thinking to substitute it in. We are huge cookie butter fans. So we would love to hear how it all works out.
25. Coleen Brown says:

    Just made these, and they are mostly still cooling. I love that this was all stuff I already had! I made a double batch with one pan being a 9x13 and then two 8x8 pans. One of the 8x8 pans I put in the freezer for about 20 minutes and they are still a little gooey, but soooooo yummy!! I’m hoping the rest will set up a little harder since they are for a freedom celerbration tomorrow night, but even if they don’t, I know they will be as big of a hit there as they were with my family!
26. [email protected] says:

    Looks yummy
27. Lyss says:

    I followed the recipe exactly, and used Betty Crocker white cake mix. I did not get a dough like texture, it's just cake with a filling. Where did I go wrong?
28. court says:

    Can you use semi sweet chocolate chips?
29. Patty Hinze says:

    I’m going to try a blend cinnamon and white chocolate chips
30. Connie Blevins says:

    Can the Cake Mix Cookie Bar recipe be frozen
31. Momma Cyd says:

    These cake mix cookie bars can easily be frozen after they have been baked and cooled.