Super Soft Sugar Cookies Recipe

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Questions & Reviews

1. Cristina @ I Say Nomato says:

   I adore soft sugar cookies! These look so delicious, I can't wait to try them!
2. Susan Rasmussen says:

   Made these for Memorial Day and my family loved them. I'm always on the look out for soft cookies, and these were wonderful. I used cream in the frosting and it also was delicious. It's great to have a sugar cookie recipe that I don't have to roll out and cut. Thanks so much.
3. Amanda says:

   Can this recipe be doubled?
4. Ann Felix says:

   love these! So
5. Ann Felix says:

   So Easy my husband loves them! Wish I could post a photo of mine! The icing was also great and made 2 dozen. I used neon food coloring and Was awesome for Christmas
6. Cyd says:

   Sure, this recipe can be doubled!
7. Amber says:

   I made this recipe for my family as a little desert. Sadly, I found that the cookies tasted too much like baking soda. I would not bake this recipe again, but if I were to, I would not use as much baking soda and also add sugar to the cookie dough recipe.
8. Bili says:

   I know you don't have to with this recipe, but will it still work if you want to roll them out and cut them into shapes or is it too soft to hold form?
9. Cyd says:

   You could roll it out for shapes. We also have other sugar cookie recipes on our blog for rolling out and using cookie cutters. https://www.sixsistersstuff.com/2012/12/santa-sugar-cookies.html
10. ALC says:

    Try the recipe again. I think it's because you used baking soda instead of baking powder. I just got through frosting my cookies and they're really good!
11. aryana says:

    about how many cookies and how much frosting does this recipe yield?
12. Cyd says:

    It makes about 24 to 30 cookies.
13. Sue says:

    Amazing recipe!! I made these with coconut in the batter and half dipped them in melted chocolate and defenitley recommend it!
14. Cyd says:

    Hi Sue! Coconut in the batter sounds delicious! Thanks so much for stopping by our blog! Have a great week.
15. Becca says:

    Unsalted or salted butter. Excited to make these!!
16. Becca says:

    Whoops, That was actually a question not a statement.... Unsalted or salted butter?
17. Cyd says:

    Hi Becca, We have actually made it with both. But I think unsalted is best.
18. GSB says:

    How many does it make?
19. Cyd says:

    This recipe makes about 3 dozen cookies.
20. Alissa says:

    These are AMAZING! It only yielded 23 cookies for me because the dough was sitting in the fridge and some hungry hands got into it haha! Both the dough and the finished cookies are delicious!
21. Sara says:

    Could I make the dough and refrigerate overnight, and bake the next day?
22. Cyd says:

    Hi Sara! You can totally make the cookie dough a day ahead and keep in the fridge overnight. Keep covered in an airtight container.
23. Deborah says:

    Do you need to do anything different for high altitudes
24. Cyd says:

    There are adjustments you can make with high altitude baking. I'm not sure what altitude you are at, but here are some links that may be helpful to you - http://www.bhg.com/recipes/how-to/bake/baking-at-high-altitudes/ http://www.pillsburybaking.com/bakers-corner/baking-basics/methods/high-altitude-baking
25. Aya says:

    Hi how are you.. can we start with the cookies right away instead of putting it in the fridge for one hour will it still come out soft.. and thank you
26. Cyd says:

    We chilled the dough for about an hour if it was too sticky. You will know when you roll them into balls if it needs to be chilled. Sometimes adding a small amount of flour will help with stickiness.
27. Gim says:

    If you don't have milk to thin the frosting, is there something else you can use?
28. Cyd says:

    Adding water will work. Milk makes it a little creamier.
29. Sandy via says:

    Can you roll it out and use cookies cutters?
30. Paloma says:

    Wow! I just baked these sugar cookies and coming from someone who does't like sugar cookies. ( I made these for my nieces school event) but these cookies are the bomb!!! best sugar cookies ever...
31. Cat says:

    Ah these were amazing! My icing came out too thin though but i think my butter was too soft so thats why. But these are amazing! My husband ate like 10 in one night lol thanks for the recipe! <3
32. Paloma says:

    It calls for baking powder not baking soda, great cookies I love them!
33. Paloma says:

    Any special instructions on how to store these cookies?
34. Cyd says:

    They store well in an airtight container. We have taken them to parties and just placed them on a plate covered with plastic wrap.
35. Rainn says:

    Yes! I did this and it works perfect! Roll it to about a quarter of an inch thick and bake at 350 works perfectly!
36. Kristina Heyden says:

    Do they spread as they bake?
37. Sammy says:

    I don't have any parchment paper. What else can I do???
38. Cyd says:

    You can use a baking mat. We have made them before without parchment paper. Watch them closely.
39. Jen says:

    I don't have parchment paper or a baking mat, is there anything else?
40. Shanna says:

    how about you READ the recipe right before putting a bad review about it. its not their fault you f*d up their recipe and then it tasted like crap. what did you expect?! baking POWDER not soda and the recipe DOES call for sugar. gosh your cookies must have been disgusting.
41. Erin says:

    Best sugar cookies ever!!
42. Cyd says:

    Just try baking them on the cookie sheet. Watch them closely so they don't get overcooked.
43. Rebecca Crenshaw says:

    What should the consistency of the batter be?
44. Cyd says:

    You should be able to roll the dough into a ball easily and then be able to flatten slightly. The consistency of most cookie dough.
45. mmartin says:

    I am new to cookie making and my cookies turned into a blob. They felt too soft and were melting in my hand I feel like I followed the instructions. I am trying again to see if they turn out better maybe I should add more flour? I sure hope I don't get berated like the last person that made an honest mistake and mentioned here. Honestly I felt like I was reading comments from Gordon Ramsey
46. mmartin says:

    They were delicious however my two yr old called the yummy pancakes ?. So if nothing else I have a great pancake recipe?.
47. Cyd says:

    Sorry they didn't turn out well. Try adding a little more flour if the dough is too sticky. Be sure they get their refrigeration time. We love comments from our viewers and try our best to help answer any questions. So glad you stopped by our blog and hope you have better luck if you make them again. Have a fantastic week!
48. Cristina Shelley says:

    These turned out nice! Thanks for sharing your recipe. ?
49. Nicole says:

    Was this rude comment really nessessary? We need more grace and kindness in this world, and less of this.
50. Grace Smith says:

    Haven't made them yet but going by the comments I'm going to, this morning! My daughter loves the frosted cookies that are so popular at stores right now, but I can't see paying those crazy prices so now I'll try yours. I will be back to post my results...
51. MO says:

    I made these with my family and dipped them in powdered sugar and cinnamon after baking instead of doing the frosting- they are so yummy! We absolutely love this recipe, thank you !!!! ??
52. Kelly says:

    Can you make the dough and freeze to bake later? Thanks!
53. Cyd says:

    This dough will freeze well. Be sure to wrap well before freezing. Thaw completely before cooking.
54. Kristen Bennett says:

    Mine aee super sticky and just looks like batter. I have added more flower but still looks runny. Batter taste great. I may have to make it like a cookie cake. An
55. Gina says:

    We baked these with our 3 year old twins today and they turned out amazing! Thanks so much for the great recipe. One question - how did you get your frosting so white? Ours was a bit off white due to the vanilla extract. Could you use food coloring?
56. Emily says:

    Can you use unsalted butter?
57. Cyd says:

    Unsalted butter will work great in this recipe.
58. Cyd says:

    You could reduce the amount of vanilla. You can color the frosting any color you want too. That is always a hit with the kids. I'm so glad they turned out and you had fun with 3 year old twins. The twins in our family just turned 2 on Dec 26. Such a fun age and with twins it's double the fun!! Have a Happy New Year!
59. Coco says:

    If you want pure white cookies, you could use white vanilla extract instead, tastes the same but doesn't give light colored baking an off-white color.... you could also go a different route and use almond extract or coconut extract, a few drops of food coloring for color, the possibilities are endless. :)
60. Nors says:

    I tried the recipe and am soooo disappointed. Don't know what I did, but the cookies are really dry. My batter was crumbly no matter how much I mixed? I checked the recipe, didn't miss an ingredient. Any suggestions? Want to try again.
61. Dauneen says:

    Love this recipe. Can I freeze these cookies after baking them.
62. Cyd says:

    These cookies freeze great in an airtight freezer container.
63. LuLuLaru says:

    I just made these for my son to take to school. Best soft sugar cookie recipe yet. Great to find one that I don't have to roll out and cut. They are kid approved from my family. I didn't have any problems with the cookie recipe being dry, or the cookies being dry. Perfect!! Many thanks!!! :)
64. Tessa says:

    I accidentally used baking soda instead of powder (I don't think I've ever had a cookie recipe call for baking powder so it was habit). Could that be causing the metallic after taste I am getting (although my husband doesn't..)
65. Silvia says:

    Hi! I don’t have a fancy stand mixer. I only have a hand held mixer. Would that change anything? What about hand mixing with a spatula? Thank you!
66. Cyd says:

    You can totally mix these cookies by hand too.
67. Silvia says:

    Just made the cookie dough .....for me it’s like sticky dough/batter .... is this normal ? I plan on leaving it overnight in fridge and rolling it out tomorrow to cut into bunny shapes... I feel like I did something wrong ?! Used the handheld mixer ??? help!
68. Veni says:

    Hi! Did you try adding a bit of flower? Sometimes that helps!
69. Mayra says:

    I made this recipe for my daughters and OMG!!!! The cookies are amazing, fluffy and soft. This is the best recipe I’ve ever come across for sugar cookies. Follow the recipe to the “T” and you will get scrumptious and out of this world sugar cookies.
70. Barbarainnc says:

    Please make this clickable. ? ❤ ?
71. Cyd says:

    Here it is just for you! :) Santa Sugar Cookies
72. April Dixon says:

    Exactly. Thank you. It's an easy mistake to make when you're not familiar with baking. I'm a great cook, but terrible at baking. I actually didn't realize her mistake until the first comment gently pointed it out. Grace and kindness go a lot further than a humiliating tone and obscenities.
73. Deborah Jeneary says:

    Can hardly wait to try!
74. Mia Moreno says:

    I tried the recipe it was pretty good as a basic muffin recipe. If you are the type who like t sweet I would advise for you to put at least 7x the amount it states. But besides that it was pretty good, it’s going to be breakfast as it turned out tasting like a plain pancake. Maybe next time I’ll add some fruits.
75. Mia Moreno says:

    Whoops I just realized I commented on the wrong recipe lol
76. Lisa says:

    My daughter made these cookies and when she went to make the frosting she had problems. 3 Tbsps of butter to 2.5 cups of icing sugar does not mix up creamy. Am I missing something because most people are raving and no one seems to be having the same issue. Wondering what we are doing wrong. Thanks!
77. Cyd says:

    Adding in the milk and vanilla will help make the frosting creamy. You can add in more butter if it seems to dry. Your butter has to be very soft. Feel free to melt it slightly.
78. karen r says:

    i am going to be making these today and i was wondering if the milk and eggs should be room temperature or not. thank you
79. karen r says:

    i decided to wait to make this until i know if the milk and eggs should be room temperature also. thank you
80. Cyd says:

    We did not have our milk and eggs at room temp.
81. Cyd says:

    We did not have the milk and eggs at room temp.
82. Cyd says:

    The eggs and milk were not at room temp. Just out of the fridge.
83. Terry Wold says:

    Hello, I can't wait to cook these with my grand daughter they look amazing! On the other hand no mean comments!
84. Terry Wold says:

    You are a amazing cook!
85. teri b says:

    This may be a stupid question but do these have to be stored in the fridge because of the milk in the recipe
86. Cyd says:

    We have left these cookies out for most of the day and they are fine. If not eaten by the end of the day, you could store in the fridge in an air tight container.
87. Cyd says:

    Ha ha! Thanks Terry. Have fun with your granddaughter. :)
88. Cathy says:

    Looking forward to baking these soft cookies as my son bought storebought and the price was exhorbitant
89. Carol M says:

    I'm wondering if using beet sugar instead of cane sugar will ruin the recipe. My son bought the wrong kind, and we live far from any stores, so I'm stuck with it for a couple of weeks. These sound so good - I don't want to have to wait!
90. Terri says:

    She's not being rude -- she's being straightforward, honest and to the point lol. Really....I admire her! And she's right -- the poster needs to learn how to read and follow a recipe before slamming it online. There's a saying....measure twice, cut once. The same applies in the baking world ;)
91. Cyd says:

    We have not used beet sugar in this recipe, so not sure how it would turn out.
92. Joan S. says:

    A bit rough of a comment. Everyone makes mistakes, but don't have to be belittled for it.
93. Michaela says:

    Do these cookies support being iced with royal icing?
94. Chelle says:

    I wanted to find a good sugar cookie recipe, I came across yours. Followed the directions to a tee, they did not come out right. After putting the dough in the fridge the dough was still very sticky....awwww. I guess need to work on it more.
95. Sarah says:

    For white icing, use clear vanilla extract. :-)
96. Cyd says:

    Any icing of your choice will work just fine with these cookies.
97. Elaine says:

    Followed the recipe exactly and they were delicious ... soft , just what I was looking for in my search .
98. Tiffany says:

    How would we be able to roll out for cutouts? Just add extra flour? They are too sticky that's why I'm asking. Thank you.
99. Cyd says:

    You could add extra flour, but here is our favorite sugar cookie recipe for rolling out dough. https://www.sixsistersstuff.com/recipe/santa-sugar-cookies/
100. Tiffany says:

     Do I need to adjust anything for high altitude baking?
101. Cyd says:

     Here are some interesting tips for baking at high altitudes. https://www.wheatmontana.com/content/high-altitude-baking-how-make-your-recipes-work-mountains
102. BlackRoseKran says:

     I just made these as a treat for my husband and kid... AMAZING! I was reading through the comments... I used 1 teaspoon of baking soda instead of the baking powder (the issue is measuring them differently). I also chose to add 1/4 teaspoon of ground nutmeg and 1/4 teaspoon of ground cinnamon, as I didn't want to frost them. Turned out great! Thank you for the recipe!
103. Victoria says:

     Yes, I rolled them out and it was great!
104. Angela Burr says:

     Hi … I am looking to make sugar cookies this Christmas with my kids. I want a yummy recipe that I can roll out and use a variety of cutters. I found that the recipe Super Soft Sugar Cookies has much better reviews then the Santa one and the Super Soft Sugar Cookies look tastier. What recipe would you suggest? And what frosting would you use as I am wanting to change them with food colour? Thanks so much. Angela
105. Angela Burr says:

     I was hoping to bake one of these cookies today. Thank you
106. Cyd says:

     Hi Angela. You will be fine with both. We use the Santa Sugar Cookie recipe for nearly every holiday for sugar cookies cut with cookie cutters and frosted. Use the frosting from the Santa Sugar Cookie recipe. Just add more powdered sugar or milk as needed for the right consistency. Happy Baking!!
107. Sheila says:

     Is it really 15-16 cups of butter. Sorry if I’m reading it wrong
108. Cyd says:

     The cookies have 3/4 cup butter and the frosting has 3 Tablespoons butter. Not sure where you are reading that amount of butter. Be sure to scroll all the way down for the recipe.
109. bhschoolu2 says:

     Hello, I'm looking for a "SUPER SOFT" sugar cookie, that will stay soft. This recipe sounds so easy, but I'm leary to make the cookies because I just don't see how 1/4" thick dough rolled out, w/o sour cream or cream cheese can really make a super soft cookie that will stay soft, unless you only bake it for about 5 minutes??? I've read the comments and so many claim they are super soft, maybe you can explain some of the science behind these? bhschoolu2?? I just don't want to waste ingredients. Thanks for your help, bhschoolu2
110. Dot lang says:

     Just give me the recipe, I don’t have time to read comments. Just need the recipe. Please.
111. Adelita says:

     Reading the comments are hilarious! I’m in!
112. Cyd says:

     This is our mom's soft sugar cookie recipe that she uses for all of the holidays, not just for the Santa cookies. https://www.sixsistersstuff.com/recipe/santa-sugar-cookies/
113. D. Steele says:

     These are nice and soft - almost cake-like, and very yummy. Make sure you flatten them before baking as instructed, this helps them keep a nice shape. I rolled mine in sprinkles before baking instead of frosting them.
114. Laura D says:

     I just made these with my kids and they turned out great! Mine don’t look as flat as the picture, did I possibly not press them down enough? First time sugar cookie maker here :)
115. Momma Cyd says:

     Hi Laura. Your dough may have been just a little too thick or cold. You could always just roll a little thinner. I'm so glad they turned out for you.
116. A. Schnelker says:

     These were very easy to make. They are good, however a little on the dry side. I would have liked more sweetness in the cookie itself. Thanks for the recipe.
117. J K says:

     Had a hard time rolling out and cutting Christmas shapes into the dough. It was super sticky and chilled for over an hour and a half before rolling it out. I’m going to try this again put roll it out beforehand and then chill. Maybe that would help lift the shaped dough off and onto the pan. Instead we did what the instructions said to do.

     
118. Samantha says:

     No, she was rude.
119. Momma Cyd says:

     If too sticky just add a little bit of flour.
120. Shaye says:

     I loved this recipe, but tweeked it to my own liking. Rather than add salt and baking Soda to the plain flour. I use self raising flour. So it doesn't taste to much like baking Soda. I also wasn't fond of the frosting as it felt grainy on my teeth after eating. So instead I just used a tub of Betty crockers vanilla icing and whipped it in a mixer with some food colouring of choice.

     
121. Kiersten ochsner says:

     Hi! I just made the holiday super soft sugar cookies that is up on your site! While the cookies turned out perfect, my frosting turned out somewhat runny. I followed the recipe exactly as instructed. I was hoping you could offer some help or suggestions on what to do to make it more “whipped” like in the picture! Thank you!
122. Momma Cyd says:

     We went in and edited the frosting recipe to match the frosting on the Santa Sugar Cookies. That's one of our favorites and very popular on our website for all of our sugar cookies.