Chocolate Marshmallow Brownie Cookies Recipe

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Questions & Reviews

1. Just Jaime says:

   These look tasty! How cool you can just make your own recipe!
2. Kylee says:

   Those look delish, Cam! Keep the recipes coming! ;)
3. Michele says:

   oh my goodness, i love cutlers! i no longer live by it though. i am so happy you came up with this recipe b/c it was always my favorite cookie there. so yummy!
   Made By Meech
4. The Iowa Farmer's Wife says:

   Holy cow these look amazing!!!!
5. idesign says:

   wow!
6. Tanya @ Greetings From the Asylum says:

   I was going to leave you a nice comment, but now I don't have time. Now I need to run straight to my kitchen and turn on the oven so I can make these cookies. I hope you understand why I can't say thank you for giving me this recipe, and why I can't even finish this comm... ;)
7. Katie says:

   How much is a "cube of butter?"
8. Plain Jame says:

   @Katie - people here in Utah where I live always say a "cube" which really means a square, but they mean a stick - which is a half cup. :)
9. Rebekah says:

   How much is a cereal spoonful? Is that the same as a teaspoon?
10. way2muchtodo says:

    Same question about the "cube" of butter"! Should this be a cup?? If not, how big is a cube??
11. Camille says:

    Ha ha! Sorry about that! I learned that a cube of butter is a Utah thing . . . anyone, it's just a stick of butter (or 1/2 cup). :)
12. I got the Joy says:

    These are so good. Remind me of my childhood. I could not find a milk chocolate cake mix so I just added some powdered milk to the mix. To die for!
13. browneyedgirl says:

    what quantity does this recipe make? I'll be making them for a cookie exchange and need to make 3 dozen.
14. Six Sisters says:

    You will get right around 3 dozen. Try to keep your dough balls close to 1 inch and you should be fine.
15. Food Marriage says:

    My friend just made these for a cookie exchange I hosted before Christmas. She shared her source with me from Pinterest, which then linked back to your post here. The Marshmallow Chocolate Marshmallow Brownie Cookies were voted the best cookies of the night!! I shared the recipe on my blog and made sure to link to give credit to you for the creation of this great recipe!! Love your blog! ---BA from FoodMarriage.com
16. Mumma yumma says:

    Do these freeze well? I'd like to make them for a cookie exchange and am wondering whether I can get a jump on them?
17. Cyd says:

    They freeze great. Just have them in an airtight container or a thick freezer bag.
18. Jennifer says:

    I love trying new recipes! I too thought these looked wonderful and thought they would be great to make for my work cookie exchange. They sounded really easy to make and since I was going to have to make almost a 100 cookies, I thought these would be perfect. However, after the first batch I quickly changed my mind. One of most frustrating thing was "rolling" them into balls. The cake mix/eggs/veg oil created a very sticky taffy like mixture. Trying to "roll" them into balls was absolutely impossible! You can't even get the batter off your fingers. Cooking the cookies for only 5-6 minutes was no way close to long enough time before putting the marshmallows on, they were still very doughy. The marshmallow piece wasn't that big of a deal, but I found myself having to smash the cookies down inorder to get them to stay on top. Also, the frosting was terrible. I tried making the frosting a few different ways by decreasing/increasing vanilla and even powder sugar. I would have been better off using store bought frosting. Of all the recipes I've ever tried, I have never before written a comment, but I was so disappointed and frustrated with my experience that I felt I needed to share. If you're going to make these yourself, be prepared to spend more total time to create them and if you have a favorite frosting recipe I would recommend using it instead.
19. Amber says:

    These are my familes favorite cookies! We have a similar cookie shop called The Cookie Connection, they make a similar version of these and they are delicious! I found your recipe and was thrilled to be able to make this yummy cookie at home. I followed your recipe exactly and they turned out perfect! I never had any problems rolling the dough into balls, the marshmallows can be tricky but that is not a big deal. And this icing is one I have used for years as a basic frosting. This is such a simple recipe, I really don't see how anyone can have problems with it.
20. Darlene says:

    How many can I expect this recipe to make?
21. Cyd says:

    It should make around 3 dozen cookies.
22. Kristen says:

    Just made these and they were a HUGE hit!! My question is that my frosting was too thin, I made it as per recipe directions but still never really set up..... any suggestions? It was wonderful tasting and we still used it, but could have been thicker? More stiff?
23. Cyd says:

    Hi Kristen. You could add a little more powdered sugar to the frosting if it's too runny. We updated the recipe slightly, so hopefully that will help.
24. Cari says:

    I had the same problem with the batter - I'm curious if it's the brand of cake mix. But I simply scooped the batter out with a spoon, and then scraped it off onto the baking sheet with another spoon - and that worked just fine. I'm going to try these again with a different brand and see if that makes any difference.
25. Courtney Sprague says:

    I just finished frosting these delicious cookies and felt compelled to comment. They are very easy to make using the cake mix and they came out so soft! We have a Cookie Connection in town and these taste just as good - now I have to find people to share them with or I'll eat the whole batch!
26. Stacie says:

    Can I substitute butter for margarine?
27. Camille Beckstrand says:

    That will work great!
28. Momma Cyd says:

    Yes, butter will work too.
29. Ann Marie says:

    Do you have a brand of cake mix you recommend? Also, from the instructions, do you add mini marshmallows to the batter as well as put on top? It lists them as an ingredient and says to mix them so wanted to double check. Thanks
30. Momma Cyd says:

    If you scroll down to the recipe card and read #2 in the instructions it will explain when you add the mini marshmallows to the top of the partially cooked cookies. Any brand of cake mix will work fine. We usually buy a name brand.
31. HD says:

    We loved this recipe. It has become a family favorite! So easy and delicious!

    
32. Erin Mitchell says:

    These were so good!! I think my cookies were too big, because I had to throw them back in the oven, and I only got 20. So next time I’ll make them smaller and it’ll be perfect! Also, do you leave the marshmallows formed, or do you squish them down at all? Thank you for the deliciousness!!

    
33. Kinsey says:

    So I ended up with only 21 cookies and they are really small. Also I had to smush the marshmallows down into the cookie. Is that right? They are still kind of falling off. I could use some more directions

    
34. Momma Cyd says:

    When you place the marshmallows on the cookie and place back in the oven, they are sitting on top of the cookie kind of balancing on top. When they heat up they will melt and stick to the cookie. Hope this helps.
35. Momma Cyd says:

    The marshmallows can be a little tricky. You kind of balance them on each cookie and then stick them back into the oven to melt a little. Just put on enough to cover the top of the cookie. When they start to melt they stick to the cookie. So taking them out of the oven is much easier!
36. Leslie May says:

    Hi, I tried to make this but your recipe said cake mix (which I had on hand) and you really meant brownie mix- whoops. I know that it said that in the Heading but I searched for cake mix cookie and that's what I got. Just thought I would let you know :)
37. Momma Cyd says:

    You want to use a cake mix for these cookies. They are made after a popular chocolate marshmallow brownie recipe on our website. We just turned them into a cookie. https://www.sixsistersstuff.com/recipe/moms-famous-chocolate-marshmallow/
38. Amber says:

    I can't stop making these cookies! They are so good especially the 2nd and 3rd day.

    
39. Momma Cyd says:

    This is what we love to hear!! Ha Ha!! So glad you are enjoying the recipe. Have a great week!!
40. Kellie says:

    It’s important in the first step to explicitly state that the marshmallows are not mixed in with all the ingredients. My teenager and her friend learned the hard way today that the marshmallows do not go into the cookie dough and to read a recipe all the way through before starting 😂
41. Momma Cyd says:

    I went in and changed the recipe so it's not so confusing. Thanks for letting us know.