Name: Mom’s Easy Strawberry Freezer Jam (only 5 ingredients!) Recipe
Prep time: 45 min
Total time: 45 min
Ingredients: 3¼ cups crushed strawberries*; ¼ cup lemon juice; 1 box MCP Pectin ((must be MCP pectin)); 4½ cups sugar

This recipe has changed because MCP Pectin has changed it's formula. The recipe for this strawberry freezer jam no longer contains corn syrup as one of it's ingredients. Follow the new directions below for a tasty jam your family will love.

Mom’s Easy Strawberry Freezer Jam (only 5 ingredients!)

When we were growing up, I don’t ever remember having store-bought jam. My mom would whip out a million batches of this jam every summer and we would eat it year-round. After I moved out, I remember sneaking jars of jam out of the freezer so that I could take it to college. I still remember having to buy my first jar of store-bought jam after I got married and being so disappointed in myself for not making my own jam. Well, after 8 years of marriage, I am happy to announce that I finally made my own . . . and I don’t know what took me so long!! It was seriously so easy . . . and my husband RAVES about it. He now thinks I am a domestic goddess. This recipe is for MCP pectin only. We’ve tried the other pectins and it turns out runny.

If you have ever wanted to try homemade jam, I promise that this recipe is simple and fail-proof!

Mom’s Easy Strawberry Freezer Jam (only 5 ingredients!) Recipe

7 cups

Prep Time 45

Total Time 45

Save Print

Ingredients

▢ 3¼ cups crushed strawberries*
▢ ¼ cup lemon juice
▢ 1 box MCP Pectin, (must be MCP pectin)
▢ 4½ cups sugar

Equipment

Instructions

Wash and cut the tops off all the strawberries. Place in a large bowl.
Mash the strawberries (I used a good ol' potato masher and it works great!). If you like chunky jam, leave more chunks. Remember that the strawberries will continue to break down even more as you add other ingredients.
Place the crushed strawberries in a large mixing bowl.
Add in the lemon juice.
Then stir in the MCP pectin into the berries. Set aside and let set for 30 minutes. Stir about every 5 minutes to dissolve the pectin.
After 30 minutes stir in the sugar gradually. Stir until the sugar is dissolved and an no longer grainy.
Pour jam into prepared containers. Leave about 1/2 inch at the top for expansion during freezing. Cover with lids.
Let stand at room temperature for 24 hours or until set.
Then place in the freezer.

Notes

*My mom always uses this recipe for peach jam, apricot jam, and raspberry jam. They are all just as delicious! Just substitute whatever fruit you want for the strawberries.
This recipe has been changed because MCP pectin has changed over the years. We used to follow the recipe that had Karo syrup in it. That recipe no longer works with this pectin. The result is runny jam. But this new revised recipe seems to work well.

Nutrition

Calories: 544 kcal · Carbohydrates: 141 g · Protein: 1 g · Fat: 1 g · Saturated Fat: 1 g · Sodium: 16 mg · Potassium: 114 mg · Fiber: 2 g · Sugar: 132 g · Vitamin A: 9 IU · Vitamin C: 43 mg · Calcium: 13 mg · Iron: 1 mg

Cuisine: American

Course: Side Dish

Did You Make This Recipe?We’d love to hear your thoughts! Leave a review or a question in the comment section below the post.

Questions & Reviews

Carol says:

Camille, this sounds delicious and I want to try it. I have not had very good luck with freezer jams, always turn out runny. I use the pectin that is specifically for freezer jams. Your recipe does not state which pectin to use. Please clarify if you use just the regular pectin or the one for freezer jams. I have never seen a recipe quite like this one. Adding the corn syrup is definitely different. As well as the cooking time in the microwave. Please clarify the type of pectin. Thank you. Enjoy the blog and have made many of the recipes.

Tara says:

I definitely am going to try this recipe. Do you know if any fruit will work with this recipe?

Evelyn says:

I have made jam and jellies but never freezer jam! How cool that you are passing down a family recipe:) I am pinning this!

Six Sisters says:

Yes! I forgot to mention that! I have tried raspberries, peaches, apricots, and blackberries and they have all turned out awesome!

Six Sisters says:

Hi Carol! I just use regular fruit pectin, not the freezer kind. It does say on the box that it is specifically for homemade jams and jellies (at least on the MCP box it does). I wonder if the corn syrup and mircowaving help make it not runny? It really is not runny at all. I hope that it works for you!

Shauntelle says:

Do you suppose I could substitute honey for corn syrup?

Shauntelle says:

Do you suppose I could substitute honey for corn syrup?

Shauntelle says:

Do you suppose I could substitute honey for corn syrup?

**momzgonenutz** says:

I don't get why it's called freezer jam...Do you leave it in the freezer and take it out for each use and then put it back in the freezer? Or does it just mean that it can be frozen until you want to use it and then keep it in the fridge like you normally do with jam??? Thanks for the help!

Carol says:

Thanks for your reply. I will try this soon. Am hopeful it will not be runny. I have never heard of MCP brand. We have Sure Gel and Ball where I live. I'll let you know how it turns out! My grandchildren love my fresh strawberry jam, runny or not, but I would like for the consistency to be right. Occasionally it will turn out right and I have often wondered if my pectin box was old--or somehow not working when it is runny--but it happens too often for that to be the cause. I follow the directions precisely! Frustrating.

Camille says:

I honestly don't know! My mom and grandma have been making this forever using corn syrup . . . let us know if you try it and if it works!

Camille says:

I think that it's called freezer jam because you make it in large batches and store the extra containers that you are not using in the freezer. It tastes amazing when you pull it out of the freezer in the winter because it's so fresh. :) And yes, keep it in the freezer til you are ready to use it, then you just keep it in the fridge like you normally do with other jam. Hope that helps! :)

Carol says:

Well, I tried it yesterday and it was still very soft last night and checking this morning, it is still very soft/runny--left it on the counter for 24 hours per SureGel instructions. Not firm at all. I followed the instructions precisely, using the exact measurements given, nothing substituted or different at all. Used Sure Gel as I have never seen or heard of MCP. I think it is even runnier than the regular freezer jam I have made using the pectin specifically for freezer jam from Sure Gel. I'm at a loss to understand what I am doing wrong. I will research the problem with Google and see if I can find any answers. I'm now wondering if I can pour all the jam back into a bowl and add more pectin......thank goodness my grandchildren all like it runny or not! But I am very frustrated! I hope others who try this recipe will post their outcome.

Jules says:

Hi Carol -
I have tried this recipe twice in the last two weeks - both using a box of sure-gel, measuring carefully etc. and both times it turned out runny and didn't set up at all. Not sure what we are doing wrong - but just wanted to let you know that you're not the only one! :)

Luckily my kids will eat it anyway...

Good luck on future batches!

M and M says:

My batch is runny too! So disappointing!

FutureHouseWife13 says:

I made this today and it turned out great! Followed all the directions and measurements, too. I'm so glad k found this recipe! I'll definitely be making it with all kinds of fruit from now on! Thank you!

Cherrye says:

Can I use strawberries that have been frozen already? I have pureed strawberries from the last time they were on sale in my freezer, I was wondering if I thaw them if it would be the same?

Ashley says:

Amazing flavor, but mine is runny as well...unfortunately I made 2 batches so now I have 6 quarts of pancake syrup! Ha! Any thoughts on how to thicken it?

Camille says:

You could definitely try it! I don't see why it wouldn't work . . . let us know!

Camille says:

I am so sorry that it came out runny! I know that sometimes with recipes, the altitude and humidity of where you live play a role in how it turns out (our sister in Missouri always has to adjust the recipes that we make in Utah or California). Anyway, I am not sure how else to thicken it up? I am so sorry!

Camille says:

My mom said that microwaves come in all different "strengths" and maybe to increase your microwave time? Just an idea...

Six Sisters says:

Tried it with Sure Gel and turned out runny. MCP Pectin is the one you will want to use for this. Turns out nice and not so runny.

Six Sisters says:

Fresh strawberries work the best!

Nada says:

I made the jam today. It cooked in the microwave for 10 min and never got bubbly around the edges. I took it out anyway but it separated in the jars and yes, it is runny. I used Ball Classic Pectin that comes in a plastic jar. It says 6 Tbsp = 1 box, so that's how much I used. Hoping it will be thicker after it freezes. If not, I guess it will make good ice cream topping.

Six Sisters says:

Our mom swears by MCP pectin only. We have made the changes to the recipe above.

Mike and Patti says:

For those who do not have MCP Pectin in your stores, it is available on Amazon Grocery. Just a thought - I'm thinking that's what I may have to do!

Bethany says:

Is MCP pectin made by sure gel? I found it (currently unavailable) on amazon that says MCP pectin and has the sure gel mark in the corner. Any ideas where else I can purchase it?

Cyd says:

Not sure where you are, but in Utah we found it at fresh Market and associated food store chains like Bowman's in Kaysville. Must have MCP in big letters on the box. Even though the boxes are almost identical. Sure gel doesn't cut it. Good luck finding it.

Patrick Sheehan says:

I am going to make this tomorrow with your recipe from strawberries I picked myself today in Arlington, Washington. I wonder if the reason some folks jam is runny is because they use store bought strawberries from California that are always half white in the middle. Or are they more runny when you use fresh picked that are completely red all the way through.I am sure other parts of the country have good berries too but I just think northwest strawberries have tremendous taste.Thanks I'll let you know how mine come out as it's my first time.

Cyd says:

Just be sure your Pectin in MCP! :)

Tiffany says:

Hoping to try this, but apparently MCP pectin is only available on the west coast. Bummer! http://www.kraftbrands.com/surejell/products.aspx

gina gentry says:

Help...I can't find mcp pectin anywhere! Any ideas???

gina gentry says:

With tax it's $34.00 s box on Amazon grocery!!!

gina gentry says:

Does anybody that can find the MCP Pectin want to sell any on ebay??? I can't find it here in NC & it's just too expensive on Amazon!

Cyd says:

We found some at Wal Mart. Have you checked there?

Cyd says:

Try Walmart.

gina gentry says:

I have checked every store around here & still can't find the right pectin. :-(

crystal says:

What does the pectin do?

Cyd says:

The pectin is what thickens it up. You need pectin in this type of jam.

Shanna says:

I tried making this on Monday and it is so runny! It tastes delish, which is great, but I'm not sure what I did wrong. I followed the directions to the T, and used the MCP Pectin. Any thoughts? I also tried making your orange creamsicle popcorn and it was a hit! Thanks for the fun recipes!!

Cyd says:

Not sure what could have gone wrong. Did you drain any extra liquid off of the fruit after mashing it a bit? You will want to drain the liquid. Did it thicken up when it was in the microwave?

Bonnie says:

I finally gave up trying the freezer jam. It is not that hard to make the cooked jam. My first batch of that came out runny, but when I talked to someone at a strawberry farm, they said not to use super ripe berries, and to increase the pectin. It turns out perfect now. I make several batches as soon as we go berry picking. My grandson watches the shelf and reminds me when there is only a couple jars left. Then I make it from the berries I froze. The only problem with the cooked jam is that you have to have the equipment to do it, but it is worth it. Love lots of your other recipes.

Alice Clark says:

Runny or not it can still be used. Have never made freezer jam but wonder if I could bottle it instead of freeing it.

Ginger says:

For all of you that wound up with runny jam why don't you try adding more smashed strawberries. I've done this with other things and it thickened it right up. Just a thought.... This recipe looks good and i LOVE strawberry jam.

Angie says:

Mine is super runny too. I'm sorry yours didn't turn out, but it makes me feel like I'm not just a big idiot!!!

Angie says:

Can't find any MCP Pectin. Frustrating!!!

Angie says:

So after reading all the posts and looking at my runny, syrupy "jam," I decided to give it one last-ditch effort. I dumped into a pan all the containers that had been cooling on the counter and cooked the stuff on the stove until it was a nice rolling boil. I then put it back into the containers and it is now setting up and looking more like jam. I couldn't find MCP pectin, so I had to use another brand. According to the recipe, you HAVE TO USE MCP. For those of you who couldn't find any (me), cooking it on the stove seems to have made it thicker and saved me from 10 cups of syrup. It tastes divine, so I don't want to give up!

Julie Evans says:

I tried this today and I am waiting for it to set. I really hope it doesn't turn out runny like a lot of other people mentioned! I did notice that all the fruit was floating on the top. How do you prevent this? Thanks!

Kimberly Barker says:

I picked fresh raspberries on Tuesday and followed this recipe exactly last night. I live in northern UT and used the MCP pectin. All the containers went in the freezer except one. The one in the fridge is still runny as of this morning. Any ideas on how to thicken it up? Could I put this fridge container in the microwave to "cook" a little more? I did read a comment about draining the liquid after mashing, I don't recall reading that anywhere in the recipe. Was I supposed to do that?

Madilyn Pitcher says:

I've used the older version of the MCP pectin recipe that uses corn syrup for years and it taste so much better. The new recipes do not taste the same. The original recipe calls for 3 1/4 cups crushed fruit. Your recipe calls for 3 lbs. of fruit. The rest of the recipe is the basically same except the original calls for 4 1/2 cups sugar and yours calls for 4 cups sugar. That may be why the jam is not setting up. You also let the jam sit at room temperature for 24 hours before you freeze it. Hope this helps.

Cyd says:

Hi Madilyn. I went in and changed the recipe according to the new directions on the MCP package. MCP has changed over the years and the old recipe with Karo syrup no longer works. It turns out very runny. We have made the jam on the newer MCP package and it thickens up well. I have to agree with you, the corn syrup recipe tasted a little better.

Alison says:

I’ve always used MCP. Sometimes it sets and sometimes it doesn’t. I made 2 batches of strawberry jam last night with the exact same ingredients (frozen berries work just fine). One set up and the other didn’t-go figure. The MCP website says that if it doesn’t set up pour your jam back into a bowl, add another pkg. of MCP pectin, add 1 cup sugar and stir every 5 minutes for 30 minutes. Worked like a champ!

Cyd says:

Hi Alison. I really think MCP has changed a little over the years. We have had to follow the little paper that comes in the box for freezer jam and it has worked for us.

Kriss K says:

I only use MCP and I use corn syrup. Just finished up with 6 batches of strawberry freezer jam. Everybody loves my jam. I have never had success with Sure Jell. I find MCP at Fred Meyer and Winco.

Judi says:

This is exactly the recipe I found, for my Mom's freezer jam. Mine turned out runny as well, but I used the liquid pectin. I am going to order the MCP pectin from Amazon, because it is not available here. I will try this again, because Mom's strawberry freezer jam was always perfect. Thank you for affirming this recipe. I will try again!

linda pauly says:

can I still use karo syrup in my mcp recipe and if so how much? I can't find the old recipe using karo syrup and I really liked it

Momma Cyd says:

The directions in the MCP freezer jam have changed. Be sure to follow the directions on the insert.

Join The Discussion

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Carol says:

Camille, this sounds delicious and I want to try it. I have not had very good luck with freezer jams, always turn out runny. I use the pectin that is specifically for freezer jams. Your recipe does not state which pectin to use. Please clarify if you use just the regular pectin or the one for freezer jams. I have never seen a recipe quite like this one. Adding the corn syrup is definitely different. As well as the cooking time in the microwave. Please clarify the type of pectin. Thank you. Enjoy the blog and have made many of the recipes.
Tara says:

I definitely am going to try this recipe. Do you know if any fruit will work with this recipe?
Evelyn says:

I have made jam and jellies but never freezer jam! How cool that you are passing down a family recipe:) I am pinning this!
Six Sisters says:

Yes! I forgot to mention that! I have tried raspberries, peaches, apricots, and blackberries and they have all turned out awesome!
Six Sisters says:

Hi Carol! I just use regular fruit pectin, not the freezer kind. It does say on the box that it is specifically for homemade jams and jellies (at least on the MCP box it does). I wonder if the corn syrup and mircowaving help make it not runny? It really is not runny at all. I hope that it works for you!
Shauntelle says:

Do you suppose I could substitute honey for corn syrup?
Shauntelle says:

Do you suppose I could substitute honey for corn syrup?
Shauntelle says:

Do you suppose I could substitute honey for corn syrup?
**momzgonenutz** says:

I don't get why it's called freezer jam...Do you leave it in the freezer and take it out for each use and then put it back in the freezer? Or does it just mean that it can be frozen until you want to use it and then keep it in the fridge like you normally do with jam??? Thanks for the help!
Carol says:

Thanks for your reply. I will try this soon. Am hopeful it will not be runny. I have never heard of MCP brand. We have Sure Gel and Ball where I live. I'll let you know how it turns out! My grandchildren love my fresh strawberry jam, runny or not, but I would like for the consistency to be right. Occasionally it will turn out right and I have often wondered if my pectin box was old--or somehow not working when it is runny--but it happens too often for that to be the cause. I follow the directions precisely! Frustrating.
Camille says:

I honestly don't know! My mom and grandma have been making this forever using corn syrup . . . let us know if you try it and if it works!
Camille says:

I think that it's called freezer jam because you make it in large batches and store the extra containers that you are not using in the freezer. It tastes amazing when you pull it out of the freezer in the winter because it's so fresh. :) And yes, keep it in the freezer til you are ready to use it, then you just keep it in the fridge like you normally do with other jam. Hope that helps! :)
Carol says:

Well, I tried it yesterday and it was still very soft last night and checking this morning, it is still very soft/runny--left it on the counter for 24 hours per SureGel instructions. Not firm at all. I followed the instructions precisely, using the exact measurements given, nothing substituted or different at all. Used Sure Gel as I have never seen or heard of MCP. I think it is even runnier than the regular freezer jam I have made using the pectin specifically for freezer jam from Sure Gel. I'm at a loss to understand what I am doing wrong. I will research the problem with Google and see if I can find any answers. I'm now wondering if I can pour all the jam back into a bowl and add more pectin......thank goodness my grandchildren all like it runny or not! But I am very frustrated! I hope others who try this recipe will post their outcome.
Jules says:

Hi Carol -
I have tried this recipe twice in the last two weeks - both using a box of sure-gel, measuring carefully etc. and both times it turned out runny and didn't set up at all. Not sure what we are doing wrong - but just wanted to let you know that you're not the only one! :)

Luckily my kids will eat it anyway...

Good luck on future batches!
M and M says:

My batch is runny too! So disappointing!
FutureHouseWife13 says:

I made this today and it turned out great! Followed all the directions and measurements, too. I'm so glad k found this recipe! I'll definitely be making it with all kinds of fruit from now on! Thank you!
Cherrye says:

Can I use strawberries that have been frozen already? I have pureed strawberries from the last time they were on sale in my freezer, I was wondering if I thaw them if it would be the same?
Ashley says:

Amazing flavor, but mine is runny as well...unfortunately I made 2 batches so now I have 6 quarts of pancake syrup! Ha! Any thoughts on how to thicken it?
Camille says:

You could definitely try it! I don't see why it wouldn't work . . . let us know!
Camille says:

I am so sorry that it came out runny! I know that sometimes with recipes, the altitude and humidity of where you live play a role in how it turns out (our sister in Missouri always has to adjust the recipes that we make in Utah or California). Anyway, I am not sure how else to thicken it up? I am so sorry!
Camille says:

My mom said that microwaves come in all different "strengths" and maybe to increase your microwave time? Just an idea...
Six Sisters says:

Tried it with Sure Gel and turned out runny. MCP Pectin is the one you will want to use for this. Turns out nice and not so runny.
Six Sisters says:

Fresh strawberries work the best!
Nada says:

I made the jam today. It cooked in the microwave for 10 min and never got bubbly around the edges. I took it out anyway but it separated in the jars and yes, it is runny. I used Ball Classic Pectin that comes in a plastic jar. It says 6 Tbsp = 1 box, so that's how much I used. Hoping it will be thicker after it freezes. If not, I guess it will make good ice cream topping.
Six Sisters says:

Our mom swears by MCP pectin only. We have made the changes to the recipe above.
Mike and Patti says:

For those who do not have MCP Pectin in your stores, it is available on Amazon Grocery. Just a thought - I'm thinking that's what I may have to do!
Bethany says:

Is MCP pectin made by sure gel? I found it (currently unavailable) on amazon that says MCP pectin and has the sure gel mark in the corner. Any ideas where else I can purchase it?
Cyd says:

Not sure where you are, but in Utah we found it at fresh Market and associated food store chains like Bowman's in Kaysville. Must have MCP in big letters on the box. Even though the boxes are almost identical. Sure gel doesn't cut it. Good luck finding it.
Patrick Sheehan says:

I am going to make this tomorrow with your recipe from strawberries I picked myself today in Arlington, Washington. I wonder if the reason some folks jam is runny is because they use store bought strawberries from California that are always half white in the middle. Or are they more runny when you use fresh picked that are completely red all the way through.I am sure other parts of the country have good berries too but I just think northwest strawberries have tremendous taste.Thanks I'll let you know how mine come out as it's my first time.
Cyd says:

Just be sure your Pectin in MCP! :)
Tiffany says:

Hoping to try this, but apparently MCP pectin is only available on the west coast. Bummer! http://www.kraftbrands.com/surejell/products.aspx
gina gentry says:

Help...I can't find mcp pectin anywhere! Any ideas???
gina gentry says:

With tax it's $34.00 s box on Amazon grocery!!!
gina gentry says:

Does anybody that can find the MCP Pectin want to sell any on ebay??? I can't find it here in NC & it's just too expensive on Amazon!
Cyd says:

We found some at Wal Mart. Have you checked there?
Cyd says:

Try Walmart.
gina gentry says:

I have checked every store around here & still can't find the right pectin. :-(
crystal says:

What does the pectin do?
Cyd says:

The pectin is what thickens it up. You need pectin in this type of jam.
Shanna says:

I tried making this on Monday and it is so runny! It tastes delish, which is great, but I'm not sure what I did wrong. I followed the directions to the T, and used the MCP Pectin. Any thoughts? I also tried making your orange creamsicle popcorn and it was a hit! Thanks for the fun recipes!!
Cyd says:

Not sure what could have gone wrong. Did you drain any extra liquid off of the fruit after mashing it a bit? You will want to drain the liquid. Did it thicken up when it was in the microwave?
Bonnie says:

I finally gave up trying the freezer jam. It is not that hard to make the cooked jam. My first batch of that came out runny, but when I talked to someone at a strawberry farm, they said not to use super ripe berries, and to increase the pectin. It turns out perfect now. I make several batches as soon as we go berry picking. My grandson watches the shelf and reminds me when there is only a couple jars left. Then I make it from the berries I froze. The only problem with the cooked jam is that you have to have the equipment to do it, but it is worth it. Love lots of your other recipes.
Alice Clark says:

Runny or not it can still be used. Have never made freezer jam but wonder if I could bottle it instead of freeing it.
Ginger says:

For all of you that wound up with runny jam why don't you try adding more smashed strawberries. I've done this with other things and it thickened it right up. Just a thought.... This recipe looks good and i LOVE strawberry jam.
Angie says:

Mine is super runny too. I'm sorry yours didn't turn out, but it makes me feel like I'm not just a big idiot!!!
Angie says:

Can't find any MCP Pectin. Frustrating!!!
Angie says:

So after reading all the posts and looking at my runny, syrupy "jam," I decided to give it one last-ditch effort. I dumped into a pan all the containers that had been cooling on the counter and cooked the stuff on the stove until it was a nice rolling boil. I then put it back into the containers and it is now setting up and looking more like jam. I couldn't find MCP pectin, so I had to use another brand. According to the recipe, you HAVE TO USE MCP. For those of you who couldn't find any (me), cooking it on the stove seems to have made it thicker and saved me from 10 cups of syrup. It tastes divine, so I don't want to give up!
Julie Evans says:

I tried this today and I am waiting for it to set. I really hope it doesn't turn out runny like a lot of other people mentioned! I did notice that all the fruit was floating on the top. How do you prevent this? Thanks!
Kimberly Barker says:

I picked fresh raspberries on Tuesday and followed this recipe exactly last night. I live in northern UT and used the MCP pectin. All the containers went in the freezer except one. The one in the fridge is still runny as of this morning. Any ideas on how to thicken it up? Could I put this fridge container in the microwave to "cook" a little more? I did read a comment about draining the liquid after mashing, I don't recall reading that anywhere in the recipe. Was I supposed to do that?
Madilyn Pitcher says:

I've used the older version of the MCP pectin recipe that uses corn syrup for years and it taste so much better. The new recipes do not taste the same. The original recipe calls for 3 1/4 cups crushed fruit. Your recipe calls for 3 lbs. of fruit. The rest of the recipe is the basically same except the original calls for 4 1/2 cups sugar and yours calls for 4 cups sugar. That may be why the jam is not setting up. You also let the jam sit at room temperature for 24 hours before you freeze it. Hope this helps.
Cyd says:

Hi Madilyn. I went in and changed the recipe according to the new directions on the MCP package. MCP has changed over the years and the old recipe with Karo syrup no longer works. It turns out very runny. We have made the jam on the newer MCP package and it thickens up well. I have to agree with you, the corn syrup recipe tasted a little better.
Alison says:

I’ve always used MCP. Sometimes it sets and sometimes it doesn’t. I made 2 batches of strawberry jam last night with the exact same ingredients (frozen berries work just fine). One set up and the other didn’t-go figure. The MCP website says that if it doesn’t set up pour your jam back into a bowl, add another pkg. of MCP pectin, add 1 cup sugar and stir every 5 minutes for 30 minutes. Worked like a champ!
Cyd says:

Hi Alison. I really think MCP has changed a little over the years. We have had to follow the little paper that comes in the box for freezer jam and it has worked for us.
Kriss K says:

I only use MCP and I use corn syrup. Just finished up with 6 batches of strawberry freezer jam. Everybody loves my jam. I have never had success with Sure Jell. I find MCP at Fred Meyer and Winco.
Judi says:

This is exactly the recipe I found, for my Mom's freezer jam. Mine turned out runny as well, but I used the liquid pectin. I am going to order the MCP pectin from Amazon, because it is not available here. I will try this again, because Mom's strawberry freezer jam was always perfect. Thank you for affirming this recipe. I will try again!
linda pauly says:

can I still use karo syrup in my mcp recipe and if so how much? I can't find the old recipe using karo syrup and I really liked it
Momma Cyd says:

The directions in the MCP freezer jam have changed. Be sure to follow the directions on the insert.